I personally don't think there should be a "ban" on barbed hooks. As i haven't been fishing that long i can't really argue as to which are the best. That is why i also had a forum named "Barbed or Barbless, what's your opinion?" Upon reading the replies to my topic it gave me a better understanding of which type of hook to use and when. There will be certain situations where a barbless hook will be best suited, e.g. for small silver fish so that the hook can be easily removed. However, there will also be times when an angler thinks that a barbed is best situated. I use them so that i don't lose as much fish, but further, in depth reading of the topic i created revealed to me that barbed hooks also decrease the chances of a tear in the fishes mouth. Overall though, i think the quote "each to their own" answers all this controvesy. Finally, Breadflake Ash, there will be times when YOU have used a barbed hook, you know you have.