Jump to content
cannibalspinners

Otter friend or foe

Recommended Posts

Hunting otter with hounds has been practised in the UK for hundreds of years (an otter hunt is described by Izaak Walton in the Compleate Angler)

otterhunt.jpg

 

 

 

To say that the otter hunts "wiped them out" is just ill informed nonsense.

 

The decline in numbers was first reported by the hunts and they stopped hunting voluntarily long before any ban came into force.

 

 

...and the anti-hunting brigade never even noticed <_<


 

 

RNLI Governor

 

World species 471 : UK species 105 : English species 95 .

Certhia's world species - 215

Eclectic "husband and wife combined" world species 501

 

"Nothing matters very much, few things matter at all" - Plato

...only things like fresh bait and cold beer...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

if otters decimated fish stocks they would have died out millions of years before man appeared ,its very handy to blame things when the real reason is man himself ,perhaps not directly killing fish but pumping sewage into rivers and interfering with nature in many other ways.

its not that otters were supposed to kill fish but that otters killed fish the land owners fished for generally game fish ,when fish eat fish its fine but when fish eat my fish its a different story.

 

rivers still generally belong to land owners ,once owners of thousands of acres with keepers but now many estates have been split up so the notion of my fish is less so otters not so much of a problem ,owners of lakes can easily take measures that will exclude otters rivers are not so easy

Edited by chesters1

Believe NOTHING anyones says or writes unless you witness it yourself and even then your eyes can deceive you

 

There is only one opinion i listen to ,its mine and its ALWAYS right even when its wrong

 

Its far easier to curse the darkness than light one candle

 

Mathew 4:19

Grangers law : anything i say will  turn out the opposite or not happen at all!

 

"To compel a man to furnish contributions of money for the propagation of opinions which he disbelieves and abhors, is sinful and tyrannical." Thomas Jefferson

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
its not that otters were supposed to kill fish but that otters killed fish the land owners fished for generally game fish ,when fish eat fish its fine but when fish eat my fish its a different story.

 

I once read an old riverkeeper's manual from the 19th century - it was basically a list of common riverside wildlife, and how best to kill it! If it wasn't silver or spotty, it was for the chop.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Also, could you direct me to some "studies" other than opinion - say like the scat surveys I posted - that indicate otter are predators of fish over 3 lbs (or fish at all)? The EA has run extensive studies but you don't seem to have an inclination for science.

 

Phone

 

Does anyone have a link to these studies by the EA that otters don't usually kill fish over 3lb? I'm certainly surprised. Someone I know with a small private stretch of River Kennet told me nearly all the chub and pike in his stretch had been killed by otters; I suppose most of the chub would have been under 3lb, but he'd found two 15lb pike left on the bank, stomachs bitten open, but not much of the fish eaten. We've all heard stories of expensive big carp being killed by them. I accept that the carp pools are artificial, but it doesn't seem to fit with otters not eating big fish.


john clarke

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Does anyone have a link to these studies by the EA that otters don't usually kill fish over 3lb? I'm certainly surprised. Someone I know with a small private stretch of River Kennet told me nearly all the chub and pike in his stretch had been killed by otters; I suppose most of the chub would have been under 3lb, but he'd found two 15lb pike left on the bank, stomachs bitten open, but not much of the fish eaten. We've all heard stories of expensive big carp being killed by them. I accept that the carp pools are artificial, but it doesn't seem to fit with otters not eating big fish.

 

 

Sounds like someone is exagerrating to me :rolleyes: . Otters don't concentrate on one spot on the river, they move up and down and mainly eat eels, crayfish and then I think trout are their favourite fish. They don't like pike because of the bones you know :D .

 

There's otters, mink, cormorants, kingfishers, goosander, herons and Polish on my local rivers and i've never come across these type of incidents...15lb pike lying all over with their guts pulled out, sounds like a prank to me !

 

Maybe his stretch of the river doesn't suit the fish at this time of year.

Edited by Tigger

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I must admit I have problems trying to imagine an otter pulling out a pike that weighs as much as the otter does.


The problem isn't what people don't know, it's what they know that just ain't so.
Vaut mieux ne rien dire et passer pour un con que de parler et prouver que t'en est un!
Mi, ch’fais toudis à m’mote

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Tench,

 

As stated in my post my source was the Missouri Department of Conservation. However, I notice in their referrences the following two from England sponsored by the EA. You might check them out.

 

Chanin P (2003) Ecology of the European Otter - and - Crawford A (2003) Fourth Otter Survey of England 2000-2002.

 

What was actually said was 1.5kg (I called that 3lbs as a "neighborhood" reference).

 

It only makes sense they would take the easiest fish first. (In MO it's not even fish otters are after). But when the pick'uns get slim I bet things could get exciting.

 

Phone

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Sounds like someone is exagerrating to me :rolleyes: . Otters don't concentrate on one spot on the river, they move up and down and mainly eat eels, crayfish and then I think trout are their favourite fish. They don't like pike because of the bones you know :D .

 

There's otters, mink, cormorants, kingfishers, goosander, herons and Polish on my local rivers and i've never come across these type of incidents...15lb pike lying all over with their guts pulled out, sounds like a prank to me !

 

Maybe his stretch of the river doesn't suit the fish at this time of year.

 

Maybe room for some exageration as regards weights Ian but I know the stretch FT is talking about. There's very little chance of anyone getting into the premises and I'm pretty sure the owner's account is accurate. 100 yards downstream I can fish on a club ticket, it's been a banker chub swim for another AN contributor for 20 years. Last year there were a couple of otter sightings and this year the chub have gone.

 

Not conclusive I'll admit, if I was a chub I'd simply bugger off to another part of the river and I haven't found any carcasses on the bank but it does make you wonder.


It's never a 'six', let's put it back

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Maybe room for some exageration as regards weights Ian but I know the stretch FT is talking about. There's very little chance of anyone getting into the premises and I'm pretty sure the owner's account is accurate. 100 yards downstream I can fish on a club ticket, it's been a banker chub swim for another AN contributor for 20 years. Last year there were a couple of otter sightings and this year the chub have gone.

 

Not conclusive I'll admit, if I was a chub I'd simply bugger off to another part of the river and I haven't found any carcasses on the bank but it does make you wonder.

 

 

The thing is Chris, the first thing people point their fingers at when there's a shortage of fish is the otter, cormorant or similar. As I said otters don't just hammer one area. Also fish move up and down rivers, they don't all just hang fire in the same places all their lives so there would be other fish moving into the areas of low fish density. On my small local river there have been otters for years and I myself have found their footprints but have never seen one until recently. I walked down to where it had just been and on my first trott caught a fish proving that all the fish don't swim to the far ends of the earth because of the presence of an otter as people claim.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Here is one of the references Phone mentions.

 

Needs careful reading by would-be otter cullers.

 

http://ec.europa.eu/environment/life/proje...SMURF_otter.pdf

 

and I can't find the "fourth survey" Phone mentions, but here is the latest (the fifth)

 

http://www.environment-agency.gov.uk/stati...l_report(1).pdf

 

Of course a survey is only as good as the knowledge and effort put into it, but it is still a better starting point than the allegations of unsuccessful and disgruntled anglers.

 

Just had a read through the references.

 

I was pleased to see the presence of otters in the High Weald is noted from distribution maps drawn in 1991 and subsequently - in the thirty years before that, I suggest the "absence" is due to the absence of visits by researchers rather than the absence of otters. (they say themselves that the more recent surveys have been more comprehensive)

 

It bears out what I said in an earlier post - that otters in the High Weald never really went away.

 

...and the otter's "preferred foods" (when available), seem to be eels, frogs, crayfish, salmonids, percids and lastly cyprinids - in that order - much the same as humans really :lol: (and yes, I've eaten frogs' legs - they are delicious)

Edited by Vagabond

 

 

RNLI Governor

 

World species 471 : UK species 105 : English species 95 .

Certhia's world species - 215

Eclectic "husband and wife combined" world species 501

 

"Nothing matters very much, few things matter at all" - Plato

...only things like fresh bait and cold beer...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...