Is This A Roach?

[chalky632007]

Well done again with the fish Chalky and I'm pleased you took that in fun, exactly the way it was intended.

lol no problem sir if i was to argue over a 4lb fish that may have been a hybrid or a true fish i deserved to be shot, lol im still laughing at the womans weekly dig , he he thanks again m8. see us scots do have a sense of humor [well apart from glasgow rangers fans ] BUT THATS ANOTHER STORY. tight lines all......chalky. now im after a good tench our record for tench is terrible ,not like the monsters down south. lol mabie have a trip down there any water tips lads??.

 

Congratulations , that was a fish of a lifetime.

thanks m8, it was a shock of a lifetime thought it was a small carp or tench, tight lines ....chalky.

[greg long]

Congrats!

Edited July 4, 2007 by greg long

[Dick Dastardly]

Well congratulations on a new Scottish record.People knock the BRFC but Im not so sure now!

[Peter Sharpe]

Congratulations - I have seen photos of big roach in this week's angling weeklies and the dorsal fin / pectoral fin alignment was identical. It's a weird fish, but it's difficult for anybody to deny that it's a roach - just an unusual one. It certainly deserves recognition - whatever it is.

[Vagabond]

Well it can't be me, 'cos I thought that it wasn't a true roach, something didn't look quite right.

 

But well done anyway.

 

 

My sentiments entirely, a splendid fish in its own right, as I said earlier.

[chalky632007]

Congratulations - I have seen photos of big roach in this week's angling weeklies and the dorsal fin / pectoral fin alignment was identical. It's a weird fish, but it's difficult for anybody to deny that it's a roach - just an unusual one. It certainly deserves recognition - whatever it is.

hi peter /vagabond thanks lads tight lines