Seperate Carp site?

[Guest pikemaster39]

Certainly not, why add a division when we dont need one - I carp fish in the summer and pike fish in the winter but I read about all kinds of fishing on here and enjoy it all so lets keep it the way it is maximum pleasure minimum divisions

 

 

 

------------------

Andi

 

http://www.sussex-pac.co.uk

ICQ:- 3728327

SACN 0286

[Guest Newt]

As of pikemaster's vote, I make the current count 12 yes and 13 no.

[Guest Pete B]

Newt,

Analyse the statistics again allowing for who primarily fishes for carp.. statistics and poll results are perfectly valid but they need to be interpreted...

Quite often a valid question is posted on here to do with carp fishing which degenerates into a 'boilie and buzzer' debate.. and many I feel do not contribute to arguments on that level (mostly).. me for one

Happy Carping

[Guest Newt]

Pete B - a 50/50 split is close no matter how you look at it.

 

I think a more valid question would be "would anyone leave if we did get a seperate carp section".

 

I am what you would class as a all-rounder and carp are less than 10% of my angling. Still, I like to read (and nick ) ideas.

 

My personal preference is to split the topics into general, baits, tackle, tactics sections for carp, coarse (except carp), and sea as it makes searching so much easier. Still, that was way beyond the scope of this question.

[Guest MTP IN VA]

Yes, I'm with Gaffer on the trial idea too.

[Guest david platt]

NO

david

[Guest stoney]

a simple NO

[Guest Simon Newbould]

Yes...

 

Simon

[Guest NickInTheNorth]

No

[Guest phil dean]

No...but hey, it's elton's decision and I'll support him whatever.

 

------------------

phil,

JOIN ANMC TODAY