I started with telescopic ideas but I hated it when the whole lot shot back.
I also used a spinner rod. The casting went well but the control of the fish on a barbless hook was a bit wayward.
By hit and miss with cut down match rods I ended up with about 9ft as the ideal, a sorta compromise. I did tend to lean to a whip rod tip, but then I like using whip rods.
The two most common challenges were the downstream side of an overhanging willow and the wide,low road bridge. The challenge in both cases was not so much in the casting as in the striking. The slow stream flow tended to aid placing the bait where I wanted. Quite often it is necessary to draw the catch to a suitable landing position. Plus large Chub (5lb+) tend to be a bit headstrong, weell come that chunky perch (2lb+) also tend to have a mind of their own. The line can hang on to it but the rod needs to soak up the sudden moves.
Thanks for the great ideas. The commercial rods rarely offer much below 10 ft. The few that I have encountered (Shakespeare, Masterline, Abu) have been way too sloppy for the jobs mentioned above. The older glass fibre rods are more suitable. Fly rods (8s) have also been used, but I tend to end up fly fishing for chub, nothing wrong in that but I do enjoy my stick float fishing.
Clearly the