Steve
I'm sure you would agree that NO rig is 100% safe.
I was just sharing my experience with Rudd, knowing that the rig I describe is, through many many hours of personal experience, reliable and safe. I would never reccommend a set-up which I thought was unsafe or fish un-friendly. Not once have I had a breakage while using it and have landed hundreds of fish including an unexpected carp of 12.5lb on a local canal using 4lb line.
I must stress that a lighter hooklength than the mainline should always be used. My usual strains of breaking strain would be 4lb mainline with a 2.5lb-3lb hooklength, this would ensure that the weakest point would be the knot joining the two lines, as such any breakage would leave the feeder conected to the mainline and not the hooklength.
As I said, no rig is 100% safe, and I see no reason why this rig is any less safe than many others in float and feeder fishing.
I will continue to use this set-up and pass it on to anyone asking advice as my own experiences and findings tell me that, used and tied in the right way, is as safe as it gets.
By all means Steve ban this method on your waters if you disagree as thats your right, but I would be interested if you personally have witnessed any breakages when tied this way.
This post is in no way meant as a knock at yourself Steve, just an observation on my behalf.
All the best
Ant
[ 08. May 2003, 10:31 PM: Message edited by: aanthony ]