criticism required

[Guest NickInTheNorth]

I have been asked to produce some prints for sale locally, (and a calendar!). I'm not sure that the pictures I have are good enough, and I wondered if anyone would be kind enough to take a look at the following web page and give me your honest opinions.

 

I'm pretty think skinned so don't be afraid of upsetting me

 

Nick

[Simon Newbould]

Hi Nick,

 

Blimey... someone actually asking for criticism

 

I thought they were all good.... Though I thought "Clouds Over Muck" and "Red Clouds in a Big Sky" were absolutely superb....

 

I'm no art critic though Nick, just stating my personal preference... and yeah, I reckon they'd sell

 

Good Luck

 

Simon

[Guest NickInTheNorth]

Thanks for those kind words Simon, there are a few more pictures there now.

 

It's very flattering to have been asked to produce these pictures, and thats why I thought I would ask on AN for criticism. I just know that people like to do that sort of thing.

[Excalibur]

I also thought none were poor, and croft at sunset, Red Clouds, Gallanach, and Mishnish were superb. Put them up for sale on the net, and I think many folk here might buy one. Any chance of knocking out a Naked W.I Calendar while you're at it ?

[Guest Ferret1959]

Crap all flipping crap.

 

Not really they look great do you mind me ripping a couple off for back grounds on my pc.

Cheers.

 

[ 26 February 2002, 07:57 PM: Message edited by: Ferret1959 ]

[Guest NickInTheNorth]

Feel free to use as backgrounds, or email me and I'll send a higher res version of which ever you want.

 

And thanks for the comments.

 

Keep them coming.

 

Nick

[chesters1]

outrageous i have carefully examined every one in detail and nowhere can i find a topless sunbather or even one with a young girl in a sheer white bikini emerging from the water totally unaware that...........dribble

[peter morton]

Lovely photo's Nick,

You have a real talent there mate,I'd be proud to say i'd taken any of them.

Peter. :cool:

[Cranfield]

Nick, I thought they were all extremely good.

I automatically prefer the ones with no "man made" objects in them.

That land/seascape is so beautiful it doesn,t deserve man made objects.

Congratulations.

[Umber]

Hi Nick, Good pictures. Maybe one or two things that may improve a couple imo .Sunset at Gallanach;- paint out the black blob (could be a bird) as it takes the eye away from a great scene. 2 Bad day at Black Rock;- Try cropping out the two objects at the bottom of the picture.3 Clouds over Muck;- Lot of black at bottom of picture, any chance of lightening it a bit?4;- Shearwater departing;- Put some detail in the sky, clouds or colour. Cant see where the picture ends at the moment.5;- Wave and waves, Sharpen.6;- imo Candles in cave is a bit blurred. Like I say this is only my opinion but maybe worth a try. Hope you have success with your venture.ATB. :cool: