200lb Skate Vs 200lb Conger

[SandTiger]

which fish do you think will give the best fight and why????

 

Dunno, which have you caught... but then that really doesn't matter does it coz the whole purpose of this post was just to troll, wasn't it?

 

Must try harder

[Guest Feels like Winter to me]

Have read the last topic this one looks like a troll to continue where the last left off. Id love to catch either fish and the fact you have them up there in bonnie Scotland in such abundance makes me truely jelous. Id like to catch either and wouldnt care which one fought best. Fishing is more than a fight or at least it should be.

[Davy Holt]

Dunno, which have you caught... but then that really doesn't matter does it coz the whole purpose of this post was just to troll, wasn't it?

 

As are most of his posts

 

Must try harder

 

Nah don't encourage him Tiggs, the Mod's have enough work to do.

[tugmistress]

Have read the last topic this one looks like a troll to continue where the last left off. Id love to catch either fish and the fact you have them up there in bonnie Scotland in such abundance makes me truely jelous. Id like to catch either and wouldnt care which one fought best. Fishing is more than a fight or at least it should be.

 

well, i must say i agree with you but the least said about that the better as i have sent a PM on the matter.

If you would like to join us on one of our forays into the murky depths of the pentland firth at some point, you would be welcome

Edited December 3, 2005 by tugmistress

[John S]

Yes we do....

 

If you don't get on with someone, just ignore them. Don't reply to their posts, add them to your 'ignore' list, and keep these forums friendly

 

First and last warning on this thread!

[Guest C T]

Hi winter

i have caught a lot of big conger in my time but never a skate,i started this thread to break the ice but never mind

ps. thanks for the pm im looking into it

[SandTiger]

John, I'd love to answer CT's disingenuous reply, but then I might cause the thread to be locked, even by given the civil answer which it hardly deserves. But then anyone can see him for what he is and make up their own minds, I guess?

[five bellies]

The last thing that I pulled that was two hundred pounds?

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

My Wife!

[Ken Davison South Wales]

Troll or not it is a very interesting question.

 

We all know there are lots of 200lb conger out there but know one apart from longliners have ever landed one.

 

However 200lb skate have been caught and I would think it is a fair assumption that there are less of them than congers.

 

I would have to put my money on the 200lb conger being the hardess to catch.

[Grant]

Ken- have longliners really caught 200lb congers?