Words fail me

[Emma two]

The irony of beating the crap out of someone for their lack of compassion is clearly lost on some people!

 

Indeed!

 

Perhaps there is another motive for those who advocate teaching that 'violence is wrong' by inflicting violence. MaybeThey get excited ? and just want an excuse to have their sadism legitimised?

[kleinboet]

Once again the same voices on the same theme!!!

FB - Do you not know the difference between a single slap (with the proper words of admonishment) as punishment and "beating the crap" out of someone?

I have the self control to NOT to go mad but see to it that the child knows right from wrong!!

 

This is apparently the sticking point!

 

I grew up where even the need of a slap was needed - just the threat of "wait 'till your father comes home" was enough for me to behave for the rest of the day!!

[Emma two]

Once again the same voices on the same theme!!!

FB - Do you not know the difference between a single slap (with the proper words of admonishment) as punishment and "beating the crap" out of someone?

I have the self control to NOT to go mad but see to it that the child knows right from wrong!!

 

This is apparently the sticking point!

 

I grew up where even the need of a slap was needed - just the threat of "wait 'till your father comes home" was enough for me to behave for the rest of the day!!

 

You are the one banging out the same old tune (theme), and display a worrying enthusiasm for the spanking of children and young people, perhaps it extends beyone that and you are eager to spank, or see spanked those of any age?

 

I can see no other rationale for your desires, for even you cannot be so blind as to fail to see that inflicting corporal punishment does not stop perpatrators from commiting crimes, it didn't when it was used widely and there is no evidence to suggest that it would now.

[IanBass]

Im making no comment on this one!!!!! God forbid I might upset someone (yet again) and they might try toupset me

[barry luxton]

Im making no comment on this one!!!!! God forbid I might upset someone (yet again) and they might try toupset me

 

Scared are ya.

 

Wish our weak government would bring back the birch to replace the weak lily livered asbo sanctions that do not work and are a total waste of time. Might just bring some respect back and assist the to@@ers to think again about throwing animals off a great hight for thier gratuitous fun or whatever.

 

ps the second example Chris used was of a teenage girl. I would allow her some dignity, to keep her pants on at the time of retribution, err, punnishment.

Edited March 11, 2009 by barry luxton

[mr motorola]

I can see no other rationale for your desires, for even you cannot be so blind as to fail to see that inflicting corporal punishment does not stop perpatrators from commiting crimes, it didn't when it was used widely and there is no evidence to suggest that it would now.

 

Ahem.............was it used in a society such as this debacle we live in nowadays?

Hang em , Shoot em , NAIL EM UP i say.

Living off the internet and media is no good to anyone , it tells you what you want to know , in as much as they want you to know. As for your quote "..no evidence to suggest that it would now...." speaks millions in what i have just said.

 

Which superior power suggests that it wouldn't work now and more to the point , HOW do these beings know without even trying it?

 

You've lost your point without even backing it up with full proof of what you state.

 

Could i have a ticket to the REAL world please??

[Newt]

I can see no other rationale for your desires, for even you cannot be so blind as to fail to see that inflicting corporal punishment does not stop perpatrators from commiting crimes,.....

Are you implying that if you cannot 'see' (understand, believe, whatever) a thing, that it must be false and that any who do not agree with you are wrong?

 

Wow!!!

[Emma two]

Ahem.............was it used in a society such as this debacle we live in nowadays?

Hang em , Shoot em , NAIL EM UP i say.

Living off the internet and media is no good to anyone , it tells you what you want to know , in as much as they want you to know. As for your quote "..no evidence to suggest that it would now...." speaks millions in what i have just said.

 

Which superior power suggests that it wouldn't work now and more to the point , HOW do these beings know without even trying it?

 

You've lost your point without even backing it up with full proof of what you state.

 

Could i have a ticket to the REAL world please??

 

Perhaps, seeing as it was posted late in the evening, you were very tired (and posibly emotional)when you wrote this? Never the less, for the sake of manners I will try and pick through it and respond.

 

Maybe you would like to give a time, be specific to wthin a decade, where those who overstepped the norms and values of society were physically punished with pain by those from within it, and, this is the significant bit, there was no violence crime? and perhaps you could point out a contemporary example of a society where the authorities inflict pain punishments on it's citizens in order to make them conform, and show how it makes that society so much better then the one in my country which you consider a 'debacle'?

 

I have no idea why you introduce the notion of a superior power or 'beings'. My case is informed by quantifiable evidence rather than the rambling notions of one who harks back to a mythical golden age of respect, peace and harmony, which even the shallowest dip into social history will show never existed.

Edited March 12, 2009 by Emma two

[five bellies]

Once again the same voices on the same theme!!!

FB - Do you not know the difference between a single slap (with the proper words of admonishment) as punishment and "beating the crap" out of someone?

I have the self control to NOT to go mad but see to it that the child knows right from wrong!!

 

This is apparently the sticking point!

 

I grew up where even the need of a slap was needed - just the threat of "wait 'till your father comes home" was enough for me to behave for the rest of the day!!

 

 

Hello Klienie

 

I cant see why you asked the qeustion as I have never posted in any thread that I am in a qaundry over the piont, but I will awnser as best I can I am a parent and strict! My values are a only slightly alterd set of values that where passed to me by my strict parents. I however was beaten at times by my loving parents (and I still love them)as that was the convention of the age I however have never found the need to beat my children and nor have my parents or my wifes so maybe our way might have some merit, they are however well manourd and industrious. On the odd ocassion that a physical punishment was meterd out it was a tap across the legs by Mrs FB and I found out a couple of days after the event. As for diserning the differance between a punishment and beating the crap out of someone! well when ever I have done the Later it was done in temper and had little or nothing to do with Justice just me being younger and full of testosterone. I have done two jobs in my life I am a Carpenter and have worked in the Security industry either as a Bouncer or in the Corporate field.

 

working in the security industry I have witnessed a lot of violent acts and acted to prevent them I would not be expected alow someone to act violently in a area that I was asked to protect even if that violent act was an act of punishment. In short of course I now the differance.

 

I was asking what you guys think My haert is always on my sleave.

 

Im a lilly livered Lefty

Edited March 12, 2009 by five bellies

[chesters1]

i like sprouts